by Christopher Paslay
Here is a reprint of a commentary I published in The Philadelphia Inquirer last Thursday, headlined, “How about the teachers?” To comment, please click on the link below.
After six months of failed negotiations with the School Reform Commission, the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers is still without a contract. The Sept. 1 deadline has come and gone, and both sides remain at an impasse.
But can you really blame SRC members for the stalled talks? It has been a long year for them.
In March, they voted to hire Arlene Ackerman as the district’s new CEO, and I can only imagine that this was an extremely exhausting process.
First they had to work out Ackerman’s base pay – which ended up being $325,000, the second-highest superintendent salary in the country.
Then they had the task of formulating Ackerman’s retention bonus, which is estimated to be $100,000.
Next the SRC had the matter of extending the contracts of the city’s education management organizations, the private consulting firms that charge the district millions of dollars to run some of the city’s public schools.
The decision to extend their contracts must have been daunting, given that studies show these private managers perform no better than Philadelphia’s traditional public-school officials.
Last year, Research for Action, a nonprofit organization working in educational research and reform, conducted a survey on the private managers.
The report stated: “We find little evidence in terms of academic outcomes that would support the additional resources for the private managers.”
In other words, education management organizations aren’t worth the money.
How did SRC members react to this? In June, they decided to extend the contracts of 32 of the 38 privately run schools.
And then there’s the issue of renewing the contracts of Philadelphia’s charter schools.
In April, the SRC approved a new five-year term of operation for 13 of Philadelphia’s 16 charter schools whose charters were due to expire at the end of the 2007-08 school year.
As with the private managers, statistics show charter-school managers perform no better than traditional school officials.
Research for Action also published a study evaluating the performance of Philadelphia’s charters.
The study concluded: “Students’ average gains when attending charter schools are statistically indistinguishable from the gains they experienced while at traditional public schools.”
And then there are the Philadelphia Academy and Northwood Academy charter schools, both now under federal criminal investigation for missing funds and illegal land deals.
How did SRC members respond to these findings? They had a meeting of the minds and decided to approve the opening of seven more charter schools by the fall of 2009.
The SRC has had quite a busy year. This probably explains why it hasn’t gotten around to ironing out that new contract with the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers.
I mean, why make time for the teachers? All we really do is educate the kids, right? Teach them how to read, write, communicate. Mold them into critical thinkers and productive members of society.
And where has Mayor Nutter been during contract talks? Did he take the PFT’s endorsement and run? What about “Putting Children First,” his plan for public education?
As a Philadelphia public school teacher, I remember his plan well. He was supposed to use his influence as mayor to reduce class sizes, improve safety inside schools, expand programs to retain quality teachers and principals, among other things.
Of course, when Jerry Jordan, president of the PFT, put these very issues on the table during contract negotiations, the SRC balked.
Jordan wrote in a recent letter to union members that the SRC was “not willing to put into the contract any language that addresses these serious issues.”
In fact, the school district is moving in the opposite direction. According to Jordan’s letter, the SRC is now fighting for a one-year contract.
Failing charter schools and ineffective private managers get three- to five-year extensions, but the workhorse known as the Philadelphia public school teacher deserves only a one-year extension?
This is a slap in the face on so many levels.
The school district needs to get its priorities straight. It must show its teachers some respect and offer us a fair, multiyear contract.