District’s Military Opt-Out Form is Denying Students Opportunities

by Christopher Paslay


So far in 2008, there have been more murders on the streets of Philadelphia then there have been American soldiers killed in Iraq.  On December 1st, Samantha Houston, 19, became Philadelphia’s 304th homicide victim when she was shot in her North Philadelphia home before dawn. 


On November 24th, Master Sergeant Anthony Davis, 43, died after being shot by an Iraqi Security Force soldier while he was conducting a humanitarian food drop.  Davis was America’s 294th soldier killed in Iraq this year.


Why am I comparing Baghdad to the streets of Philadelphia?  Because of the “opt-out” campaign the Philadelphia School District is running against United States military recruiters.


Despite the fact that America’s armed services provide young men and women with a variety of occupational skills and the opportunity to travel the world, the school district has been working diligently to remove students’ names from lists of recruiters.  A quick visit to the Philadelphia School District’s website will reveal that a link to their “Military Opt-Out Form” is not only pasted on the front page, but also translated into eight different languages: Spanish, Chinese, Russian, Khmer, Vietnamese, Albanian, Arabic and French.   


The campaign to keep the names of Philadelphia teens off military recruiter’s lists is also being promoted inside city schools as well.  At Swenson Arts and Technology, the high school where I teach, military opt-out forms are made regularly available.  Directions for completing these forms are often announced during advisory period. 


It’s usually during this time that students in my homeroom ask if they can be excused to go to the office to pick up a form. 


“Why do you want to get your name off the list so bad?” I recently asked a young man in my classroom who requested the form. 


“Because I don’t want to get drafted,” he told me.  Others in the room agreed with him.


I tried to explain that there was no draft in the United States, that the lists were strictly for recruiting purposes so military personnel could send you information in the mail or call you on the phone.


“And you can always say no when they call,” I told the boy.  “But at least it gives you options when you graduate.”


“I don’t want to go to war,” he told me.  “I don’t want to die.” 


And that was the end of the conversation.


Although I understood his reasoning, part of me felt sorry that many students blindly close the door on such a golden opportunity.  If they kept an open mind, students would realize the United States military has so much to offer.  Instead of hanging around the neighborhood and dealing with high unemployment rates, they could serve in the Army and earn money for college.  As they did so they could learn about computers and engineering—job skills that could pave the way for a bright future once their service is over. 


Much of the same applies with the Navy, Air Force and Marines.     


Not all students reject the military, of course.  Surprisingly, a growing number of teens in Philadelphia are embracing the military through Jr. ROTC.          


At Swenson, we are privileged enough to have an Air Force Jr. ROTC program.  AFJROTC cadets are some of the best and brightest students in the building.  They are highly motivated and disciplined, often serving as escorts to visitors during school community functions, and raising and lowering the flag in front of the school every morning.  Not to mention they look incredibly sharp in their crisp, navy blue cadet uniforms. 


Despite the best efforts of teachers and principals, too many students in Philadelphia are graduating with limited skills.  The military is a perfect solution to this problem.  School district officials should be encouraging young men and women to enlist in the service, not shielding them from such an opportunity.


Although I’ve had dozens of students come back to my classroom to visit me after graduating, the ones who impress me the most are always those young men and women who have enlisted in the military. Their presence is clearly distinguishable from the rest of their peers: They are proud and confident, in amazing physical shape, and have a look in their eye like they can conquer the world.       

2 thoughts on “District’s Military Opt-Out Form is Denying Students Opportunities

  1. Knowledge is power. Every student should have ALL THE INFORMATION so they can make an informed decision about their future. Why discourage or even deny opportunities (SEE San Francisco) by not allowing recruiters to speak or give information. I just ran into a 22 year old just getting out of the Air Force. Next month he is starting his new job as “air traffic controller”–learned in the service–paying almost $100,000.00 per year. Yes, many, many skills are learned in the service that can be transferred to the civilian world. Also, the majority of Armed Services are not in Iraq or Afganistan. Let the students and parents see all the opportunites so they can choose to join or not to join. Don’t take away choice because of POLITICAL LEANINGS. Please don’t influence them–either way. Let them decide after seeing and hearing all the information.

  2. I don’t blame them but it doesn’t matter. They still have to register for selective service. It’s the law. From sss.gov website.

    If you are a man ages 18 through 25 and living in the U.S., you must register with Selective Service. It’s the law. You can register at any U.S. Post Office and do not need a social security number. Be sure to register before your 26th birthday. After that, it’s too late! Selective Service does not collect any information which would indicate whether or not you are undocumented. You want to protect yourself for future U.S. citizenship and other government benefits and programs by registering with Selective Service.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s